February 22, 2012
Steel/precast concrete system helps beat the elements in Edmonton Alta.
Winter can be a bear in Canada. Just ask any builder.
When outdoor temperatures plummet construction slows or worse - it grinds to a halt.
But improvements over the years in cold-weather building technology and materials have opened up opportunities for builders in cold snaps.
A case in point is in Edmonton, where an unusual steel/precast concrete system is being used to construct an eight-storey, 178,000-square-foot Courtyard Marriott at the Edmonton International Airport.
The building consists of a structural steel system, combined with precast concrete hollow core floor/roof slabs.
The hybrid system allows for construction in cold-weather conditions that would delay conventional cast-in-place concrete construction methods, said Peter Timler, vice-president of engineering, Supreme Group, the parent company to Supreme Steel Edmonton, the steel contractor for the Marriott.
Called the Girder-Slab System (GS), it is the first time it has been used in Canada.
Proponents see it as an alternative to cast-in-place concrete in conventional construction of midrise towers of four storeys or taller.
GS is new to Canada, but in the U.S. almost 100 midrise residential buildings have been constructed since 2004 with the system.
GS is produced by New Jersey-based Girder-Slab Technologies.
Originally, the Edmonton Marriott hotel design was conceived as a cast-in-place concrete structure.
Supreme, however, showed the benefits of the encased steel floor frame within composite precast planking for gravity loading support, said Timler.
“The interesting part of the integrated design approach was that we managed the structural information. We modelled it, we managed it and we vetted it with the structural engineer (Williams Engineering Canada Inc.) who remained responsible for the structure,” explained Timler.
“It was a very collaborative approach that allowed us to get the design done in a very short time without any hitches.”
Timler said that even the elevator and stair core for the building – typically done in cast-in-place concrete – was specified in structural steel to allow for a quicker construction schedule over winter.
The GS system consists of a modified wide-flange section that accepts hollow-core planking on the bottom flange.
Web openings in the steel D-beam allow for the hollow-core elements to be “stitched through” the steel for grouting and rebar, he explained.
Precast hollow-core slabs for the job are being supplied by Armtec, of Richmond, B.C.
The benefits of GS go beyond cold-weather applications, explained Timler.
Fewer trades are required, for example.
The steel and hollow-core erection only requires ironworkers.
Conventional construction would call for multiple trades, including trades for the structure, deck, rebar, concrete placement and floor finishing, he said.
“Girder-Slab could add a 25 per cent time savings,” Timler said.
He noted that Supreme’s calculations indicate that on some two-year cast-in-place concrete projects, GS could shave six months off build out.
GS has other attributes.
It offers builders a safe working platform once planking is down.
What’s more, the shoring required on each floor in cast-in-place construction isn’t required, he said.
“That allows follow-up trades to come on site much sooner.”
The GS system is also cost-competitive with conventional construction and will probably save an owner money over cast-in-place concrete at the Marriott, the engineer pointed out.
No special training is required for installation of Girder-Slab, but the steel contractor must accept more responsibility (not just fabrication and erection) for the project.
“The contractor has to look at the supply of the hollow-core slab and the grouting process,” he said.
Timler said the economic downturn in 2008 that slammed the U.S. residential market slowed the spread of Girder-Slab construction.
“We were into the millions of square feet of various projects moving ahead when the downturn happened and they all got pulled back,” he said.
Daniel G. Fisher, Sr. managing partner, Girder-Slab Technologies, said he sees the Marriott project in Edmonton as seminal.
“It is a tremendous opportunity to introduce owners and builders first hand to the benefits of structural steel and precast hollow-core slabs for multi-storey residential construction,” he said.
Structural steel and precast concrete require a small crew of ironworkers to quickly erect the structure and continue work despite freezing temperatures, he added.
Cast-in-place concrete is still the simplest way for an architect to design a multi-storey residence.
“It gives the architect flexibility to place the columns where he likes,” he said.
But, hybrid systems like Girder-Slab are catching on in the U.S. because they are less expensive and quick to erect, Fisher added.
|MOST POPULAR STORIES|
|TODAY’S TOP CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS|
These projects have been selected from 544 projects with a total value of $1,665,691,502 that Reed Construction Data Building Reports reported on Tuesday.
$100,000,000 Province of Alberta AB Prebid
$92,000,000 Vancouver BC Tenders
$60,000,000 Medicine Hat AB Tenders
- ERCB investigates Zama City, Alta pipeline spill
- Crystal Clear
- Regina looking to annex adjacent land
- Pipeline oil spill highlighted during twinning debate
- Consulting engineers gathering in Lake Louise, Alberta
- Biased specs grounds for RFP redraft
- Incoming chair looks to the future
- Foreign worker court case led to reforms
- Shell Canada gets approvals for pipelines and gas well
- B.C. building permits rise, but Alberta declines
- Electronic migration
- Unauthorized water system shut down in Alberta
- Ontario’s best steel designs recognized
- ACEC conference to focus on economic solutions
- Improper bypass of low bidder found
- CISC awards honours individual achievements
- Quebec construction workers on strike after failed negotiations
- Newfoundland and Labrador set to lead the way in economic growth
- Construction industry to increase hiring in 2013, according to outlook
- OCOT review panel proposing a ratio reduction for plumbers and steamfitters
- Man fined in construction site death of 12 year old Nova Scotia boy
|ALEX’S ECONOMICS BLOG|
Reed Construction Data Canada’s Chief Economist Alex Carrick discusses current developments in the North American economic environment with emphasis on the construction industry.
- An Overview of Prices and Sales in the Diverging U.S. and Canadian Housing Markets (April 25, 2013)
- Canada’s Precarious Dependence on the Commodity Price Super-Cycle (April 22, 2013)
- Twenty major upcoming residential and transportation terminal construction projects - April 2013 (April 15, 2013)